• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Dave Stuart Jr.

Teaching Simplified.

  • ABOUT
  • BLOG
  • LATEST VIDEOS
  • COURSES
  • BOOK
  • SPEAKING
  • RESOURCES
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Not a Switchboard, but a Garden

July 15, 2021 By Dave Stuart Jr. 3 Comments

When I hear how we talk about the inner workings of a person, sometimes I think we're around computers too much. The things we program can end up programming us.

Here's what I mean.

It's best to think of a student's heart not as a place filled with buttons and switches — okay, let's turn on some Credibility, let's switch on some growth mindset — but instead as a garden.

I like the garden picture better because it implies the key verb to creating a care-driven classroom: cultivate. Many actions are involved in the cultivation of a garden:

  • Prepping the soil
  • Planning
  • Planting seeds
  • Watering
  • Fertilizing
  • Weeding
  • Pruning
  • Picking

Just as many actions are involved in the cultivation of motivation. Some actions yield an outsized impact on results (e.g., seed-planting in a garden or MGCs in a classroom), but all actions are necessary for the highest possible yields.

A few more reasons I like the garden analogy:

  • Gardens are living things to be partnered with, not machines to hack.
  • Gardens, properly stewarded, can be rewarding for the gardener, just as classrooms can be rewarding for teachers.
  • Gardens aren't simple — they are complex, and effective cultivation takes practice and study. So too with a classroom filled with souls.
  • While a gardener controls many things in a garden, she does not control everything. The sun and the rain and the rabbits and the cicadas… all of these are outside of her control. So gardening is partially about adjusting to uncontrollable circumstances, preparing for them, mitigating their negative effects.
  • A gardener's work promotes the flourishing of the garden but does not guarantee it.

At any rate, I've found it a helpful mental shift — the hearts of our students are gardens, not switchboards.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Eugenia Papaioannou says

    July 15, 2021 at 11:15 am

    An amazing metaphor! It’s so much more positive to think of gardens!

    Reply
  2. Boyd Hainsworth says

    July 19, 2021 at 8:38 am

    When a friend asked his neighbor how he managed to have such a beautiful and productive garden, the neighbor replied with a simple bit of counsel; make sure you spend time in your garden each day, regardless if it is just 5 minutes or an hour. By spending time in the garden each day, you are better able to notice the subtle changes that are occurring and thereby able to make corrections. Do your plants need more water? Less water? Are insects beginning to infest your tomatoes? It’s easier to correct problems early on than happening to notice them once your plants are ruined. I love the fact that it is the gardener that needs to make the course corrections in this metaphor. It doesn’t do much good to yell at your tomato plants, “How dare you allow these hornworms to infest you! No water for you for the next week!”

    Reply
    • Dave Stuart Jr. says

      July 19, 2021 at 9:41 am

      Boyd, this is just lovely my friend. Thank you for adding it.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Copyright © 2023 ยท