• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Dave Stuart Jr.

Teaching Simplified.

  • ABOUT
  • BLOG
  • LATEST VIDEOS
  • COURSES
  • BOOKS
  • SPEAKING
  • RESOURCES
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Show Search
Hide Search

A Hidden Depth

October 27, 2026 By Dave Stuart Jr. 1 Comment

Dear colleague,

Lately I’ve been rereading Ann Hollingsworth’s The Simple Faith of Mr. Rogers: Spiritual Insights from the World’s Most Beloved Neighbor.* In its first chapter, Hollingsworth described the moment she realized that “underlying the apparent simplicity of the [Mister Rogers] program — the kind that was fodder for mockery — I suddenly saw a depth I had never noticed before. Mister Rogers was more philosopher than babysitter” (p. xx). She later goes on to describe Fred’s background in the rigorous study of both theology and child development.

The man was no stupe.

This got me back to thinking of a theme that came out during a visit I had at Parker Core Knowledge school in Colorado a month or two ago. As I was sitting in my hotel getting ready that morning, I was reading a Peps Mccrae article (his newsletter is lovely, btw) in which Mccrae argued that, paradoxically, the better someone’s teaching is, the simpler it looks to an outsider.

During my time at Parker Core Knowledge later that morning, I found myself amazed at the depth of understanding of the teachers, the earnestness of their passion, and the elegance of their school’s systems of intervention and student onboarding. It looked like a very normal school in a very normal place. Yet though it appeared normal, it was filled with experts (who as it happened were a lovely and earnest group to think with during that morning’s session on The Will to Learn).**

But I’ll admit that there is something sort of annoying about that idea that expert teaching is easy to miss. This idea that the more expert your teaching becomes, the easier it is to miss it or take it for granted. It’s sort of grating, given how hard it is to get one’s practice built up into something one could call expert teaching. But just beneath that fleeting annoyed feeling, what I find is an intoxicating reality — this idea of being so excellent in your work, so very good at what you do, that a layperson can hardly notice it.

…until you look at the impacts.

The way to spot an expert is less by how their work looks than by what it’s impact is. This is essentially where Mccrae starts in his paper “Expert Teaching: What is it, and how might we develop it?”:

There are several ways we might begin to think about expertise in teaching. The first is to consider teacher impact: the influence that teachers have on what their students think, do, and achieve.

And this brings me back to what I find so worthwhile in the study of Fred Rogers via things like Hollingsworth’s book. His program appeared laughably simplistic. And honestly, so did he! But beneath the apparent simplicity, there was an enormous hidden depth.

There’s a wonderful little clip I can use to demonstrate this to you. In 1969, a young Fred Rogers was called to testify before the Senate Commerce Committee, which was chaired by a feisty and abrasive senator named John Pastore. Rogers gets about six minutes with the guy. And in that six minutes, through slow and deliberate speech, you can watch as Pastore transforms from annoyed to awed.

I believe that the power of Rogers’ testimony flowed from the deep degree to which Rogers understood children, understood himself, and understood the obstacles to healthy child development. From this hidden depth, Rogers spoke; from this hidden depth, Rogers developed 895 episodes over 31 seasons. And lest we feel that Rogers’ world was a different one than ours, notice in the hearing clip above how Rogers is concerned with what he calls the “animated bombardment” of children. We simply live and teach in a time when bombarding young people with engagement has been perfected into things like the TikTok algorithm. But just as Rogers’ hidden depth produced an impact that ripples still today, so too can ours.

To make this article practical, I will summarize my point like this: seek expertise and understanding. Seek to see your students, their world, and the impact good teaching has. Find like-minded folks*** and do this work with them. There are many of us in education, even today, who continue to work toward this hidden depth.

Teaching right beside you,

DSJR


*I can’t recommend this book enough, or for that matter any work that aims at better understanding the life and mind of Fred Rogers.

** If you’ve got a group of rock stars I could come and think with, learn more about my speaking services here and be in touch here. Please note that I’ve got new capacity for Zoom-based mini-sessions (1-2 hours) in the afternoons. Let me know if you’d like to talk more about that.

*** I’d be remiss not to invite you to San Diego this January, where I hope and pray many like-minded people will convene to think about student motivation. Tickets are only $89 if you order by the end of November. You can learn more and order your ticket here.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Carmen Munnelly says

    October 27, 2026 at 11:35 am

    Mr. Rogers’ attention, for some children, was the only they received on any given day. He gently reared so many of us, shifting our innate self-centered viewpoint to include and care for other people, all the while teaching us so much about life. (He taught me to tie my shoes! At bathtime, I was never scared I would go down the drain!)

    Brother Dave, I’ll see you at OVCA this January, attending on behalf of two other teachers who can’t get down here.

    Brother Fred would be proud of you.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Copyright © 2026 ·